Grill Buying Guide: Gas, Charcoal, Pellet, Electric, Smokers Compared - Find Your Perfect Match

Welcome, grillmaster! The process of choosing the right cooking machine can make you a hero with your family and friends, promising delicious meats, charred vegetables, and grilled flatbreads for years to come. A whole world of shiny options is out there, and it all comes down to five hot hits: gas vs charcoal, pellet grills vs electric grills, and smokers. Whether you are a seasoned barbecue veteran or a beginner in the world of fire, this detailed comparison will help you understand the features of each, shedding light on strengths, weaknesses, and qualities to choose from.

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links, meaning if you choose to make a purchase via our links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

For our home, we chose two Traeger smokers, and in addition to providing some incredible meals for home, we have been able to smoke large amounts of meat for a few gatherings in our community already. These events were so much fun! But those stories are for another day. Ready to light the fire? Let’s get started!

Gas Grills:

Gas grills are the way to go for many outdoor cooking lovers. It is very convenient to use gas grills. You just have to push the button, and the grill is ready for cooking in a few minutes. It can reach the designed temperature quickly, while you can easily control the ratio of fat or oil to food. Some fans say although gas grills are the best for this technology, they have a noticeable flavor difference from charcoal or wood pellet grills.

Check out this Gas Grill we found on Amazon

Charcoal Grills:

Many long-time enthusiasts agree that, if you’re seeking that classic char, nothing beats the taste of food cooked over charcoal: The only way to get something you love, and that authentic smokiness, is a charcoal grill. Charcoal gets really hot, which is good for getting that crispiness on the outside of meats or vegetables. You can also use a charcoal grill as a smoker for longer cooking at very low temperatures. It is worth noting that charcoal takes more time and effort to set up and maintain an even temperature, which is the key.

Check out this Charcoal Grill we found on Amazon

Pellet Grills:

If you like the ease of a gas grill but love the full, smoky flavor of a charcoal one, consider a pellet grill. Fired by pellets of hardwood, pellet grills are more set-and-forget than gas ones. The grill automatically feeds the wood pellets at a rate that maintains a steady heat and a moderate amount of smoke. With one of these, you can grill, smoke, bake, roast, and even braise. Pellet grills are pricier than standard charcoal or gas grills, but many users say the set-and-forget operation combined with the distinctive smokey flavor, makes it worth the splurge.

We highly recommend these Traeger Pellet Grills you can get on Amazon

Difference Between Smokers and Grills:

There's an important distinction between smokers and grills; understanding it can help you pick the right appliance for your cooking needs. While smokers use indirect heat and smoke to cook food slowly at low temperatures for hours, grills use direct heat for medium- to high-speed cooking over a shorter period. This results in slightly different flavors and cooking methods. Something to keep in mind as you choose.

For those who want the ease of gas grilling with more depth of flavor than you would normally get with a gas grill, an electric smoker is a great option. Electric smokers are some of the easiest appliances to use in the barbecue world. Most have digital controls, allowing you to input your desired temperature and time settings, and they do the rest. Electric smokers burn very little wood, so they smoke less and produce next to no ash. Be aware, the flavor they produce is more subtle than that achieved in a charcoal or wood smoker.

Some purists not only don’t trust the taste of a conventional gas grill, some don’t trust the process of convection cooking — the heat that comes from below creates a convection current that circulates hot air and can make the food taste more like it was cooked in a conventional oven than a grill. Fans of barbecue love the traditional wood taste of charcoal-smoked foods. A charcoal smoker can achieve low and slow smoking, which juices the meat and adds a rich, smoky flavor not found in electric- or gas-powered smokers, or in heating up a pit full of wood. However, it takes more time and skill to set up and maintain a charcoal smoker.

In a nutshell, the best grill or smoker for you is the one that fits your personal needs and preferences. Do you enjoy backyard hamburgers and hot dogs with the family? Are you interested in a juicy, slow-cooked brisket? If you care about efficiency, taste, or versatility, any of the outdoor cooking appliances we mentioned is right for you. Go get a grill or smoker already, and be sure to let us know what mouthwatering recipes your family loves.